Antonio's New York Pizzeria
Hawaii's pizza options are basically limited to the big guys, the national chain restaurants -- Domino's, Papa Johns, Pizza Hut, Chuck E. Cheese (for the kids), and California Pizza Kitchen (gourmet). Of the smaller independent pizza joints, one of my favorites is Antonio's, which is located right across Waialae Avenue from Kahala Mall. Antonio's serves New York-style pizzas, pasta dishes, calzones, salads, hoagies and Philly cheesesteaks as well as New York cheesecakes and cannoli.
There are many options on the menu here, with most pizzas averaging between $10 and $18 depending on the size of the pie and the number of toppings. When I stopped by for lunch one recent afternoon, I found the pizzeria mostly empty.
There was just one couple and their two children enjoying some garlic rolls and a large pizza at a table in the corner of the dining area. After looking over the menu, I decided NOT to order a pizza, but instead decided on having a hoagie. You're in a pizzeria and you're having a hoagie? That's just as bad as having a burger at a seafood joint (sound familiar?).
So to save myself some frustration from having to explain myself, I'm going to start by saying that I did have the pizza here many, many times before. My favorite is the white pizza, which substitutes olive oil and sweet basil for the usual tomato sauce. More specifically, though, I usually order the Manhattan Supreme (white sauce, garlic, spinach, tomato, mushroom and Parmesan) or the Antonio's Special (white sauce, garlic, mushroom, pepperoni, black olives, Italian sausage and Parmesan).
Today, I chose the deluxe hoagie (US$5.99).
A freshly baked 9" Italian roll is stuffed with ham, Genoa salami, pepperoni, lettuce, tomato and cheese, then topped with some tangy Italian dressing. To me, this hoagie was better than any sandwich from Subway. Filled with lots of meat and veggies, it almost seemed like I ordered a sandwich and a salad. After the first few bites, I was confident that I had made the right choice.
How's about another look at the hoagie before I take the first bite?
After I was done with the hoagie, I made my way to the counter for a slice of the homemade NY cheesecake (US$2.99).
I had heard great things about this cheesecake so I was really anxious to try it. The cheesecake is baked in-house by one of the owners' wives and the recipe for the cheesecake comes from said owner's mother. Dense, moist, and creamy this cheesecake was perfect. It was served plain and it was complimented by a thin, slightly sweet crust. It's been years since I've had cheesecake this good, so I'm really glad that I decided to have this for dessert.
Antonio's New York Pizzeria
4210 Waialae Avenue
Telephone: 808.737.3333
Recent Comments